Choose the dessert habit before the machine
If your plan is to keep a vanilla base and a fruit sorbet ready for the weekend, start by considering the original NC300UK. Its seven programmes already cover several familiar frozen desserts, and it has a separate Mix-In cycle. A longer programme list is only valuable when it includes something you expect to make regularly.
The NC501UK makes a stronger case when frozen yoghurt, frappés or slush-style drinks are part of the plan. Those have dedicated programmes on the Deluxe. Write down three things you would actually make in the first month, then match those to the controls. That is a better buying test than assuming the word Deluxe guarantees a better bowl of vanilla ice cream.
What the larger tub and half-tub controls change
The Deluxe tub holds a larger batch, with a nominal 709 ml capacity in the instructions, rounded to 710 ml in the product listing. Its Top and Bottom settings let you process the upper half of a prepared base and then the remaining half. These options apply to scoopable programmes; the drink programmes use Full. Always follow the relevant fill lines and recipe rather than treating nominal tub volume as a universal ingredient allowance.
For a household with different topping preferences, processing one half with one mix-in and the other half with another can be useful. You are still starting from the same base: this is not two independent freezing compartments. If one person needs a completely different recipe or an allergen-free preparation, separate correctly labelled tubs and appropriate cleaning remain important.
Make room for tomorrow’s dessert
For frozen-base recipes, both machines depend on a separate freezer and preparation ahead of serving. Allow at least 24 hours and freeze the base level according to the model’s instructions. Neither machine is a compressor ice-cream maker that freezes a liquid mixture itself. Having spare prepared tubs is likely to make more difference to spontaneity than choosing extra programmes.
Check the space available in your freezer before choosing a tub size. A family that repeatedly finishes a batch may welcome the Deluxe format; someone who wants small amounts of several flavours may place more value on separate tubs. Do not load loose frozen fruit or plain ice and expect either machine to behave like a blender. Use recipes and accessories intended for the exact model.
Check the pack, then compare the price
Tub quantities need care. At our research check, the NC300UK’s product details and box list said two tubs, while descriptive copy on the same page mentioned three. Check the selected retailer’s included accessories before ordering, especially if comparing a standard machine with a bundle. Extra tubs are storage containers, not extra processing stations: both machines process one tub at a time.
Use the current retailer options above rather than a fixed price difference in this guide. If you would only use the shared dessert functions, the original is a reasonable shortlist choice. If the Deluxe’s portion controls and drink options solve a real need, compare that benefit with its total cost and storage requirements. This is a researched comparison; we have not tested texture, noise or processing performance side by side.
Explore each model
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How this works
Was this useful?
Tell us what needs attention. Please leave personal details out of your feedback.

